Go to main content

Search Welders Net

Welding Process Picker: MIG, TIG, Stick or Flux-Core?

By First published

Tell the picker your metal, its thickness, whether you weld indoors or outdoors and your skill level. It ranks MIG, flux-core, stick and TIG and gives the reasons, each quoted from a Miller Electric page you can open. It is a starting point, not a procedure.

Welding process picker

Results update as you change a field and are saved in the page address. Nothing leaves your browser.

Your job

18 gauge is about 0.047 in. (Miller's gauge table), 1/8 in. is 0.125 and 1/4 in. is 0.25.

Best fit first

How the picker decides

Each process gets points for how well it fits your metal, your location, your thickness and your skill, using statements from Miller Electric's guides. A process that Miller does not list for your metal, or that is below its thickness floor, is marked "not suited" and sorted last. Ties keep the order MIG, flux-core, stick, TIG.

Scoring
score = metal fit + location fit + thickness fit + skill fit
metal or thickness fit: good +2, marginal 0, not listed = excluded
location: outdoors favours stick and flux-core (+2), penalises MIG and TIG (-2)
beginner skill points: 3 minus the process rank (MIG +2, flux-core +1, stick 0, TIG -1)

Worked example

Given: mild steel; 1/4 in. thick; outdoors; some experience.

  1. Stick: steel listed, outdoors good, 1/4 in. good, skill rank 3: score 7
  2. Flux-core: steel listed, outdoors good, 1/4 in. good, skill rank 2: score 7
  3. MIG: indoors-only shielding penalised outdoors: score 3
  4. TIG: slow on thick plate, penalised outdoors: score 0

Answer: Flux-core (FCAW) comes first for this job, with the reasons listed in the tool. Change the inputs above to see how the ranking moves.

The comparison behind it

How Miller Electric describes each process
ProcessSkillMetals, thickness and wind
MIG Easiest to learnSteel, stainless, aluminum; 24 gauge up; gas shield
Flux-core Some skillSteel, stainless; 1/8 in. up; good outdoors
Stick More skillSteel, stainless; 1/8 in. up; best in wind
TIG Most skillAll weldable metals; 22 gauge up; slow on thick

Sources 1 and 2, opened 2026-11-14. Miller's two pages disagree on the thin end for stick and flux-core, so the picker treats metal under 1/8 in. as marginal for both. The 18 gauge (0.047 in.) cut-off comes from a Miller gauge table whose value is Unconfirmed: it couldn't be checked against the maker's current documentation, so follow your machine's manual.

Assumptions and limits

  • Four inputs only: metal, thickness, location, skill. Cost, input power (115 V or 230 V), duty cycle and machine availability are not scored. The duty cycle calculator covers the last.
  • Statements come from two Miller Electric pages. Miller sells equipment for all four processes, so it is a fair source for how they compare, but it is a single manufacturer's view.
  • Thickness floors differ between Miller's pages for stick and flux-core. We use the stricter reading and flag it. Treat metal near the floor as marginal.
  • We did not open sources for filler choice, pipe, code work, positions or joint design, so the picker says nothing about them.

Questions we get

Which welding process is easiest for a beginner?

Miller calls MIG the "easiest welding process to learn" and rates flux-core as needing some skill, stick more skill and TIG the most. That is why the picker leans toward MIG for beginners working indoors on clean steel.

What is best for welding outdoors?

Miller says stick electrodes are self-shielding and "better suited for windy, outdoor conditions than MIG or TIG", and that flux-core is "less affected by drafts, so better suited for outdoor work". Gas-shielded MIG and TIG rely on a shield of gas that wind can disturb.

What is the best process for thin metal?

Miller lists MIG from about 24 gauge and TIG from about 22 gauge, and says TIG is "most commonly used to join thin sections". It says stick is limited to metals no thinner than 18 gauge. For flux-core, Miller's two pages give 26 gauge and 1/8 in. as the minimum, so the picker treats thin sheet as a poor fit.

Can I weld aluminum with stick or flux-core?

Miller does not list aluminum for either process. It lists MIG and TIG for aluminum, and its engine-drive guide says aluminum TIG needs an AC output.

Why does the picker not ask about budget or power supply?

We only encode statements we could source to a manufacturer page. Miller's pages cover metal, thickness, location and skill, so those are the four inputs. For cost and input power, see our machine buying guides.

Is the answer a welding procedure?

No. It is a starting point for choosing what to learn or buy. Code work follows a qualified procedure, and your machine manual, site safety rules and an instructor come first.

Where we got this

  1. Miller Electric, "Buying Your First Welder: A Practical, Informative Guide for Do-It-Yourselfers" (millerwelds.com) Accessed 2026-11-14.
  2. Miller Electric, "Welding on the Farm: Selecting a Welding Unit for the Farm or Ranch" (millerwelds.com) Accessed 2026-11-14.
  3. Miller Electric, Engine Drive Buyer's Guide (EDBG), AC TIG section (millerwelds.com) Accessed 2026-11-14.
  4. Lincoln Electric, POWER MIG 215XT manual 11521, procedure chart footnote on Innershield NR-211-MP thickness (manualmachine.com) Accessed 2026-11-14.
  5. OSHA, 29 CFR 1910.252: Welding, cutting, and brazing, general requirements (fire prevention (a), eye protection (b), ventilation (c)) (osha.gov) Accessed 2026-11-14.
  6. NIOSH (CDC), "Welding Fumes and Manganese" (cdc.gov) Accessed 2026-11-14.
  7. NIOSH, Criteria for a Recommended Standard: Welding, Brazing, and Thermal Cutting, Publication 88-110 (cdc.gov) Accessed 2026-11-14.
  8. AWS, ANSI Z49.1 Safety in Welding, Cutting, and Allied Processes (AWS Safety and Health Committee recommends following it and the manufacturer's Safety Data Sheets) (pubs.aws.org) Accessed 2026-11-14. Listing is the 2012 edition; use the current edition from AWS.

Keep reading